Reversed call looms large in Boston winUmpiring crew ultimately gets it right in big first inning for Red Sox
After Dustin Pedroia was called out on a phantom force play in the first inning of the World Series opener, second base umpire Dana DeMuth was reversed by the other five members of his crew.
Three pitches later, Mike Napoli lined a cutter to the gap in left-center field for a go-ahead three-run double, and the Boston Red Sox coasted to an 8-1 rout over the St. Louis Cardinals on Wednesday night.
Nine years after they reversed the Curse, the Red Sox succeeded in reversing a key Series call.
''You rarely see that,'' Napoli said before adding, ''especially on a stage like this.''
Jacoby Ellsbury had walked leading off the first, and Pedroia had singled with one out. David Ortiz followed with a slow bouncer to second baseman Matt Carpenter that had an outside chance of being turned into an inning-ending double play.
Carpenter made a routine 30-foot backhand flip to Pete Kozma in plenty of time for the out. But as the shortstop approached second base, the ball bounced off the edge of his glove's webbing and fell to the ground.
DeMuth called Pedroia out on a force, indicating the ball was dropped by Kozma while making the transfer to his throwing hand.
''It was just one of those plays. He gave me a good feed and I just missed it,'' Kozma said.
Red Sox manager John Farrell jogged out from the dugout out to argue.
''I think we're fully accepting of the neighborhood play, but my view is that it wasn't even that,'' he said. ''There was really no entry into the glove with the ball.''
All six umpires huddled near shortstop for 30 seconds to discuss the play as Farrell looked on from the infield grass.
''Typically they're probably going to stand pat with the decision that's made in the moment,'' Farrell said.
Kozma believed he established sufficient possession.
''I had enough,'' he said.
And then crew chief John Hirschbeck then walked toward the Cardinals dugout on the third-base side, motioning with his left hand for Cardinals manager Mike Matheny to come out. He told him that Pedroia was being called safe, and Matheny spent 1 1/2 minutes arguing to no avail, repeatedly jabbing his right index finger in the air.
''That's not a play I've ever seen before,'' Matheny said. ''And I'm pretty sure there were six umpires on the field that had never seen that play before either. It's a pretty tough time to debut that overruled call in the World Series. Now, I get that trying to get the right call. I get that. Tough one to swallow.''
DeMuth admitted he got it wrong.
''I stayed with the foot too long. That's how I ended up getting in trouble,'' he said. ''And when I was coming up, all I could see was a hand coming out and the ball on the ground. All right? So I was assuming.''
When he saw his crewmates converging on him, DeMuth knew he had made a mistake.
''It's an awful feeling, yeah. Especially when I'm sure I have the right call,'' he said.
Hirschbeck said in the end it wasn't a difficult decision for the crew.
'''When I hear all five of us say we are 100 percent, then I say, 'OK, we need to change this.' It's as simple as that,'' he said.
Major League Baseball started using video review to assist umpires in 2008, but only to decide whether potential home runs went over fences or were fair balls.
Under rules changes likely to be approved for next season, video will be used for virtually every call other than balls and strikes. Managers would be allowed one challenge over the first six innings and two from the seventh inning on. Officials in New York City would make the final ruling.
Speaking softly in a corner of the cramped visitors' clubhouse, Kozma seemed like a player who felt he had let his team down.
''You saw what happened the rest of the night,'' he said. ''If I catch that ball and turn that double play, it stays nothing-nothing.''